Rent stabilization and rent overcharge cases for New York City tenants

A large number of New York City apartments have left rent stabilization over the past three decades. Some left lawfully. Many did not.

If your apartment was deregulated improperly, the law may treat it as still rent stabilized. That can mean a stabilized lease, a lower legal rent, a refund of what you overpaid and, in some cases, additional damages.

We represent tenants in these cases, and we review them for free.

Signs your apartment may have been illegally deregulated

  • Your DHCR rent history shows a sharp rent increase with no explanation.

  • Your rent history shows the apartment leaving rent stabilization with no reason given.

  • Your rent history has gaps, or the landlord stopped registering the apartment.

  • Your landlord says renovations took the apartment out of stabilization, but the apartment does not look like it had that much work done.

  • Your building receives, or once received, J-51 or 421-a tax benefits.

  • Your building has six or more apartments and was built before 1974.

None of these proves a violation. Each is a reason to look closer.

What we handle

  • Rent overcharge claims in Supreme Court and at DHCR

  • Challenges to deregulation based on apartment improvements, high-rent vacancy, J-51 or 421-a benefits, and substantial rehabilitation

  • DHCR proceedings, including responses and appeals

  • Nonpayment cases where the rent the landlord is demanding may itself be unlawful. An overcharge can be both a defense and a counterclaim.

We never evict tenants

This firm does not bring eviction cases. Not for any landlord, in any court. Our rent stabilization practice is built on representing tenants, and we will not take work whose purpose is to put someone out of their home.

How a case works

  1. Free case review. Send us your address, your lease and your DHCR rent history if you have it. If you do not have it, we will show you how to request it. The request is free.

  2. We investigate. We compare the rent history against leases, Department of Buildings filings, tax benefit records and whatever else the building's paper trail offers.

  3. We tell you where you stand. You get our view of the strength of the claim, the realistic range of outcomes, the risks, and your options, which may include negotiation, a DHCR complaint or a lawsuit.

  4. If we take the case, we pursue it. You will know the plan and the fee arrangement in writing before you sign anything.

Common questions

My lease says the apartment is market rate. Does that end it?

No. A lease cannot waive rent stabilization. If the apartment is legally stabilized, a market rate lease does not change that.

How far back can I recover?

It depends on when the overcharge happened and on the facts. The rules changed in 2019 and have been heavily litigated since. We will tell you which rules apply to your apartment.

Can my landlord retaliate against me for asking questions?

New York law prohibits a landlord from retaliating against a tenant for asserting legal rights. We will talk through the practical risks with you before you decide to do anything.

I already moved out. Is it too late?

Not necessarily. Former tenants can have claims too, subject to time limits. Contact us sooner rather than later.

Free case review

Tell us about your apartment. Start with the building address, since we need it before we can speak with you. Submitting this form does not make you a client of the firm.